Vindicated Covid-19 Models Warn Pandemic is Far From Over

Modelers have watched with a mixture of horror and frustration as their projections of the pandemic's evolution have come to fruition.

When the coronavirus pandemic hit the United States this year, scientific models forecasting hundreds of thousands of deaths were met by some people with derision.

The models, unfortunately, have been vindicated. And they're providing fresh warnings that a recent uptick in numbers of cases could mean the U.S. death toll could almost double in the next four months.

"If we go back to March, at that time, we were saying if this thing is not handled very carefully, we could end up with 200,000 or 300,000 deaths," said a coronavirus modeler, Alessandro Vespignani, director of Northeastern University's Network Science Institute. "At that time, everyone was saying that's impossible. I think we should use that perspective now, especially when we think about the future."

After beating back an initial wave of coronavirus infections, some countries in Europe find themselves in familiar territory: facing a spike in the number of new cases and weighing which restrictions could help drive the numbers down. In the U.S., after a brief dip earlier this month, the number of new cases daily is creeping up again. Since Sept. 18, the seven-day average of new Covid-19 cases in the country hasn't fallen below 40,000 a day, according to an NBC News tally.

For coronavirus modelers, the writing has been on the wall. Many have watched with a mixture of horror and frustration as their projections of the pandemic's evolution, and its potential death toll, have come to fruition.

Now, a widely cited model developed by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of Washington suggests that the U.S. could total more than 378,000 coronavirus deaths by January.

But infectious disease modeling can be a tricky science easy to criticize for its uncertainties. Experts say coronavirus models have come a long way since the early days of the pandemic, to the point where some researchers are moving away from long-term projections and focusing instead on forecasts that can more accurately predict Covid-19 trends up to six weeks.

Not all the models were accurate. Their biggest mistake came in terms of Africa, where some predicted severe outbreaks. Instead, much of the continent has avoided the worst of the pandemic.

The director of the institute, Dr. Christopher Murray, a professor of health metrics sciences at the University of Washington, said his team's U.S. model has undergone numerous refinements throughout the pandemic. Behavioral changes — such as diligent mask-wearing — could drive their projections for January down, but he also worries about fatigue settling in.

Murray said the new trajectory can already be seen in some European countries, including Spain, France and the United Kingdom.

That's why modelers are hoping people heed their warnings about the coming weeks, when, they say, growing complacency and changing behaviors tied to the fall and winter seasons could result in a new wave of infections.

"I think some people think the worst is over," he said. "That progressive decline in vigilance will fuel part of the fall and winter return."

The University of Washington institute's model, which is one of several the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention uses to track the pandemic, has been criticized for often including high degrees of uncertainty, which can lead to imprecise predictions. Early on, the model underestimated the number of Covid-19 deaths nationwide, projecting that the U.S. could hit 60,415 by the end of August.

Still, the model is updated frequently, and refinements are made as data on case numbers, hospitalizations and a host of other factors become available. By June, the institute's model was estimating that the U.S. death toll could hit 200,000 by Oct. 1, a projection that ended up being accurate to within two weeks.

But infectious disease models are never static, and several unknowns could significantly alter the existing projections.

One such factor is how the virus's spread may be affected by the changing seasons. No firm evidence suggests that the coronavirus will be more or less transmissible in the fall and winter. Rather, it's the effect that falling temperatures have on human behavior that concerns researchers, particularly because cold weather is likely to draw people indoors and make it difficult to practice social distancing.

"In the winter, people tend to stay inside, which could make it easier to transmit the disease," said Sen Pei, an associate research scientist at Columbia University, who has done extensive Covid-19 modeling work. "But we still don't know how the virus will perform in the winter."

Pei said that there were enormous challenges with modeling a novel coronavirus but that with nine months of data from the pandemic, his team's projections have become significantly more sophisticated. Yet one of the most difficult things to predict in a model is also one of the most important factors that could change the outcome of an outbreak: how humans respond.

"It's a fluid situation, because people's behavior changes over time, which is essentially unpredictable," Pei said.

The uncertainty is partly why Pei and other modelers avoid long-term projections like the institute's model and focus instead on producing short-term outlooks for the next four to six weeks.

"Nobody really knows what's going to happen past the next few weeks," said Youyang Gu, a data scientist who runs a coronavirus model known as Covid-19 Projections. Gu, who doesn't have a background in epidemiology or infectious disease modeling, designed a model that uses machine learning to "study" certain parameters that evolve with the pandemic, such as the virus's reproduction number, or R-naught, which represents how contagious a disease is.

"We don't rely on any implicit assumptions," Gu said. "We look at the data and say: This is what we learned from what is happening."

Gu said his model, which runs forecasts only until November, was able to predict that the surge in new cases in June and July wouldn't subsequently lead to an equivalent spike in deaths on par with what the country experienced in March and April.


Protect your employees and customers with minimal distraction and effort

Automated Temperature Screening is effortless and creates a safe trusted environment that eases the tension, fear, and anxiety people often feel after a pandemic. 

Automated Pass Management Temperature Screening Device. This device requires no physical interaction. Simply look at the camera and get the temperature in 1 second. Facial recognition checks-in and maintains records of the individual temperatures. Designed to help protect the health and safety of both employees and guests by preventing anyone with a temperature from entering a facility. it’s the perfect solution for office buildings, warehouses, schools, government buildings, museums, sports arenas, theme parks, movie theaters, gyms, rail stations, hotels, restaurants, or practically any public venue.

Protect your employees and customers with minimal distraction and effort.

TempSafe Technology makes temperature screening easy. Explore our site to learn more about our Temperature Screening products.

Temperature Screening Solution

Safely screen employees and visitors for high temperature as they walk into a building or a defined area. The system can prevent people from entering if the pre-defined temperature threshold is exceeded or are not wearing a mask, and trigger an alarm.

  • Provides fast and accurate body-temperature measurement
  • Detects if a protective mask is being worn
  • Users can be denied door or system access if a high temperature or no mask is detected
  • Alarm options include strobe light, siren and popup on PC workstation 
  • Saves data in personnel safety log and verifies records.
  • Data, alerts and reporting available

The solution combines a thermal camera and our latest face, palm and fingerprint recognition technology for employee authentication, providing advanced security and convenience, all on a single affordable device.

Used to help screen potentially affected people in the workplace and public venues:

Schools, airports, hospitals, construction sites, correctional institutions, government and office buildings

No Touch Biometric Reader

Embedded face & palm recognition sensor provides 100% hands-free hygienic user authentication.

  • Used for various applications including Access Control, Time & Attendance, Visitor Management, Event Management & more
  • User authentication read range up to 8 feet
  • Face verification possible while wearing protective mask (Palm recognition advised while wearing mask)
  • Dual-lens IR & VL camera recognizes faces in both total darkness and bright sunlight 
  • Access Levels, Groups, Holidays, DST, Duress Mode (password), Anti-Passback, Record Query
  • Interfaces with
    • KeyTracer Key Control Systems
    • AssetTracer Smart Locker Systems
    • Various Access Control Systems